"Women who are resilient and successful have
incorporated creative rituals into their daily routines."
Stories of successful women often reflect the struggles they have
overcome to reach great heights of excellence. What made the difference
in these women when many others were unable to tame the demons that
invaded their lives? This article examines the resiliency factor
of several successful women and identifies their ability to rebound
from early hardship to lead normal, fulfilling lives through the
use of rituals and relationships.
Webster's (1989) definition of resilience is "an ability to
recover from or adjust easily to change or misfortune. Roget's Thesaurus
(1985) uses the word "elasticity" when listing synonyms.
Resiliency is defined by Higgins (1994) as the ability of "subjects
to negotiate significant challenges to development yet significantly
'snap back' in order to complete the important developmental tasks
that confront them as they grow". Walsh (1998) simply defines
resilience as the "ability to overcome life's challenges".
However we define the term "resilient", most definitions
focus on the strengths of the individual versus those traumatic
events they may have encountered in their past.
In psychological and sociological literature, resilience describes
people who possess the ability to recover from adversity while retaining
a positive self-image and view of the world or who, because of their
early home life, are at risk for developing personal and social
problems (O'Gorman, 1994). Holocaust victims and children growing
up in abusive homes have been described as resilient because of
their ability to retain a positive self-image and view of the world.
Psychological resiliency, according to Patricia O'Gorman (1994),
encompasses all aspects of the self: emotion, intellect, and spirit.
How resilience manifests itself depends upon the individuals/s own
worldview and means of coping with life. Literature addressing work
with survivors of troubled families, identifies the ability, this
inner strength to weather life's challenges and consistently come
out on top as the quality of resilience (O'Gorman, 1994 & Wolin
& Wolin, 1993).
Other studies on resiliency mention an easygoing temperament and
a higher level of intelligence. Rutter (1985) identified a strong
sense of self-esteem as the critical component for being resilient.
Seligman (1990) described learned optimism as an important individual
trait in which people believe their actions and efforts can yield
success. If we examine the literature on resiliency, we find the
repetition of terms in describing this attribute. Studies mention
an easygoing temperament, and a higher level of intelligence. Rutter
(1985) identified a strong sense of self-esteem as the critical
component for being resilient. Learned optimism (Seligman, 1990)
is an important individual trait in which people believe their efforts
and actions can yield success.
Rituals
The case studies of the successful women presented in this article
describe how each was able to access rituals on a regular basis
to maintain balance in their lives. Rituals are the repetitive acts
that we perform daily and in special times to create this precarious
balance. Incorporating these rituals consists of preparing for them,
experiencing them and reintegrating them into everyday life (DeTrude
& Stanfield, 1998). This repetition of the ritual helps create
a much-needed sense of continuity in our lives by linking generations
to one another and then becomes the lens to viewing family and close
friend relationships. Using rituals help a person create a protected
time and space to make meaning out of how their lives have been
and where they are going, and when we are discussing individuals
who have experienced trauma and pain, this consistency of the ritual
helps to guide them emotionally to a "safe" place. Our
self image and the image we have of others are developed in part
through a process of identification between the individual and larger
groups, be they ethnic, religious, political or whatever; rituals
allow us to preserve ties, even during turbulent times (Imber-Black,
1992).
There are four basic types of rituals. The daily ritual creates
an organized framework from which people guide their lives. This
type of ritual is perhaps the most significant when we speak of
individuals being carried through everyday trauma. The other types
of rituals are also very important and serve as strengthening tools
for individuals, but they may be less influential in developing
"hardiness" or "resiliency" simply because they
occur less often in life. The second category is that of the family
ritual and focuses on how families celebrate birthdays and anniversaries.
They are strictly celebrations of the family and not printed on
any commercial calendar. The third type of ritual is that of holiday
celebrations that are common to the community and the larger system
as a whole. The last type of ritual is for those events that take
us from birth to death, how the family recognizes the birth of a
child, graduation, marriage and death. While this last type can
also be very significant in overcoming trauma, rituals of this type
occur less often.
If we focus on the daily type of ritual, we can summarize some
rituals mentioned by successful women leaders. They refer to playing
soft music, keeping flowers or candles in their offices. They also
mention rituals to avoid stress - not listening to the news before
bedtime, driving "backroads" to avoid freeway traffic.
Regardless of the examples given, women who are resilient and successful
have incorporated creative rituals into their daily routines.
Resources
The second factor that seems to explain how women can achieve resiliency
when facing multiple problems is that of being able to access resources.
For the purposes of this article, we will define resources as significant
others/mentors in the lives of resilient women. In their study of
successful academicians, Bland and Schlitz (1986) register mentoring
as one of the criteria responsible for guiding their careers. Mentoring
is described as a process of noncompetitive teaching and guidance
for those who share one's interests. Aspy and Sandhu (1999) assert
the importance of developing "good old women" networks
aside from the connections usually associated with volunteering.
Case Studies
The following case studies represent a diverse group of women,
but the one factor that ties them together is resiliency that has
persisted through difficult times.
Maya Angelou - Poet Laureate
When her parents' marriage ended, she and her brother went to live
with her grandmother. In that community there was a strong network
of African-American women who participated in church-related activities
and who served as powerful role models for compassion, grace and
courage (Ashy & Saddhu, 1999). One of these supporters was a
woman named Mrs. Flowers who encouraged and helped Maya with her
reading. Uncle Willie, the grandmother's disabled brother, also
lived in the home. These family members and Mrs. Flowers were the
resources that encouraged and supported Maya throughout her childhood.
When Maya was eight, her father took her to her mother's home for
a visit, and during that visit she was raped. This was such a traumatic
experience for her, and she did not talk for two years after the
event. During this silent period, the ritual of writing poetry served
as the healing process. Her grandmother and Mrs. Flowers continued
to encourage her in reading this poetry which was the vehicle for
ending this period of silence. When Maya found herself in periods
of turmoil throughout her life, she relied on this creation of poetry
to guide her out of the pain. The poem, "I Know Why the Caged
Bird Sings" is an account of her childhood up until the time
of the birth of her child when she was 16. In an interview given
in 1995, Maya was asked what she would say to a sixteen-year-old
who sees the world as so bleak. Her response was, "I would
read. I would read everybody, all the time" (Kelly, 1995).
Years later, Maya's son, Guy, had experienced a terrible accident
and was undergoing emergency surgery. Maya immediately fell back
upon a ritual that had sustained her throughout life - prayer. She
immediately reached out to a support and prayer network of friends
from all denominations to pray for him. The doctors had told her
he was paralyzed and would never walk again. She told them he would
walk out of the hospital and said, "I'm going so far, so beyond
you, you're not even in it" (Kelly, 1995). Maya's dependence
on writing and spirituality supported her through many instances
of trauma and is still mentioned by her today as the sustenance
that provides her with strength and continuity.
Sandra Day O'Connor - U.S. Supreme Court Judge
When one first looks at Supreme Court Justice O'Connor, one sees
success and many firsts for a female who has attained such a high
position in the courts. Upon examining her life, this view changes
to let the reader know resiliency was a key component for reaching
the current status on the highest court. Sandra grew up on an isolated
ranch that had no phones and no neighbors. She learned from a very
early age to be self-sufficient (Aspy & Sandhu, 1999). Her daily
rituals at a young age consisted of animal care on the farm. She
learned to brand bulls and perform other necessary farm chores.
Recognizing the intellectual potential of their daughter, her parents
sent Sandra to live in El Paso with her grandparents when it was
time for high school, because their local school did not have all
the academic resources they wanted for their daughter. As a child
and then as a teenager, her supportive resources continued to be
family members who wanted her to be challenged academically. She
went on to Law School at Stanford, graduating third in her class,
but back in 1952, she was in male territory and was offered a legal
secretarial position while her male classmates were placed in prestigious
law firms. She detoured her own professional career to travel and
live overseas with her husband. She started to accept limited roles
in political campaigns after returning to this country and gradually
climbed through the ranks in these political campaigns to achieve
the position she has today. In the presidential election between
Reagan and Carter, the polls showed that Reagan was trailing Carter,
so Reagan made the announcement that he was going to appoint a woman
to the Supreme Court. After that announcement, he never trailed
in the polls again (Aspy & Sandhu). When a vacancy occurred
on the Supreme Court in 1981, Reagan followed through with his campaign
promise and interviewed O'Connor. Reagan's Attorney General, William
French Smith, was the responsible party for calling O'Connor and
offering her the position. Ironically, he was also the attorney
who had offered her a secretarial position years before when she
had graduated from law school (Aspy & Sandhu, 1999).
Sandra also underwent a mastectomy and chemotherapy in 1988 and
was courageous in sharing this with other women. Sandra has had
multiple resources in her life, one being the MPU (Mobile Party
Unit), an organization which does not allow husbands at their activities.
The rituals of caring for animals as a very young child provided
her with discipline; the isolation on a ranch solidified her self-reliance.
Sally Ride - Astronaut
Sally Ride was born in 1951 to parents who truly valued education,
her father was a professor and her mother a teacher and a counselor
at a women's correctional unit, so in this family environment Sally
knew how to read by the age of five. She was also very much interested
in sports and was often the only girl in the neighborhood to play
with the boys. As she got older, her daily rituals in practicing
tennis provided her with discipline and a high level of skill so
that she went to college on a tennis scholarship (Ashy and Sandhu,
1999). At times she did encounter prejudice for her interest in
physics which was viewed by others as a major for only males. Dr.
Elizabeth Mommaerts who introduced Sally to the significance of
science and problem solving was a major resource and mentor for
her (Aspy & Sandhu 1999). Sally continued to be a promising
scholar and became interested in the astronaut program. She was
one of the first women to be inducted into the astronaut program,
and the first American woman in space. She saw herself as a resource
and mentor to all the other women in the space program who were
aspiring to follow in her footsteps. After the Challenger explosion,
Sally did not have the opportunity to fly in space again, but she
actively served as a consultant on safety issues with the space
program and went on to academia where she is a Professor of Physics
at University of California, San Diego.
Conclusion
These three case studies reflect the importance of resources and
rituals in obtaining success and providing the foundation for overcoming
racial, cultural and sexual discrimination. One interesting commonality
with these three women is their desire and ability to mentor others
and give to others those crucial resources that they had experienced
through their journey. This "giving back" is an identified
factor that defines who these women are today.
REFERNCES
Aspy, C. & Sandhu, D. (1999). Empowering women for equity:
A counseling approach.
Alexandria, VA: American Counseling Association.
Bland, C. & Schmitz, C. (1986). Characteristics of the successful
researcher and implications for faculty development. Journal
of Medical Education, 61 (1).
DeTrude, J. & Stanfield, V. (1998). The gift of ritual in creating
balance. In G. Brown & B. Irby (Eds.), Women and leadership:
Balancing power with caring. (pp. 21-36). New York:
Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
Higgins, G. (1994). Resilient adults: Overcoming a cruel past.
San Francisco, CA: Jossey- Bass, Inc.
Imber-Black, E. & Roberts, E. (1989). Creating rituals in therapy.
Family Networker, July- August.
Kelly, K. (1995). Visions: Maya Angelou [on-line]. Available:
http://bsd.mojones.com/mother_jones/mj95/kelly.html
Mish, F. (Ed.). (1989). The new Merriam-Webster dictionary.
Springfield, MA: Merriam- Webster Inc., Publishers.
Morehead, P. (Ed.). (1985). Roget's college thesaurus. New
York: Penguin Books USA Inc.
O'Gorman, P. (1994). Dancing backwards in high heels: How women
master the art of
resilience. Center City, MN: Hazelden Educational Materiels.
Rutter, M. (1987). Psychological resilience and protective mechanisms.
American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 57 (3).
Seligman, M. (1992). Learned optimism: How to change your mind
and life. New York: Pocket Books.
Walsh, F. (1998). Strengthening family resilience. New York:
The Guilford Press.
Wolin, S. & Wolin, S. (1993). The resilient self: How survivors
of troubled families arise above diversity. New York: Random
House.
Dr. Judith A. DeTrude is an Assistant Professor at Sam Houston
State University.
edu_jad@shsu.edu
Vicki S. Stanfield is the Coordinator of Shared Counselor
Program at North Harris Montgomery Community College District.
AWL
Journal Home Page
AWL
Journal Volume 3, Number 1, Winter 2000
|